Rule of Law Conditionality Mechanism for Member States of the European Union Upheld by the EU Court of Justice, Rejecting Court Actions by Hungary and Poland: What Does This Mean for the EU?

Which European Union (EU) Member States are qualified to obtain EU money?

The EU's official judicial answer is now clear:
only those Member States that respect "the Rule of Law".

See in this regard the EuroNews.com article at ECJ [European Court of Justice] rules in favour of making EU cash handouts conditional on a country's respect for rule of law 

and the article video here.

The decision-making court in the case, the EU Court of Justice, the European Union's highest court, was tweeted at Twitter via the EUCourtPress as follows:

#ECJ rejects the actions brought by #Hungary and #Poland against the #EUBudget conditionality mechanism on the respect of the #RuleOfLaw by Member States @Europarl_EN @EUCouncil
— EU Court of Justice (@EUCourtPress) February 16, 2022

The ultimate consequences of this decision by the EU Court of Justice on the EU application of the "Rule of Law Conditionality Mechanism" are still unclear, although the holding has potentially unsettling ramifications for the European Union, exposing problematical differences between "East" and "West" Member States in their views on democracy and sovereignty. How are these differences to be remedied in a healthy union?

 

As written at EuroNews.com:

"How did the ECJ case come about?

Budapest [Hungary] and Warsaw [Poland] brought the legal action against the European Parliament and the EU Council, the bloc's two co-legislators, in early 2021.

During the legal case, the institutions were supported by interventions from the European Commission, which drafted the original proposal, as well as from Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Ireland, Spain, France, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Finland and Sweden [all Member States in the West]." [material in brackets added]

The "Rule of Law" question decided by the EU Court of Justice can also be seen as significant in view of the current Ukraine situation as regards Russia and NATO. Ukraine is located on the ancient trade route between East and West. It is a place of geopolitical conflict historically.

See in this regard:

• Jonathan Masters, Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), Ukraine: Conflict at the Crossroads of Europe and Russia
  
  
• NATO Multimedia Library, LibGuide, NATO-Russia Relations, About the Controversy over the 'NATO Expansion' Point during Reunification Negotiations
  
  
• Michael Mccgwire and Michael Clarke, NATO expansion: ‘a policy error of historic importance’, International Affairs, October 2008, 84(6):1281 - 1301, DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-2346.2008.00769.x

 

Wissenschaftsforschung und die Rolle von Memen und Memetik: Was definiert die wahre Wahrheit? A Stunningly Good Google Translate German Language Translation of the English LawPundit Original Posting

In the right column of LawPundit, we offer the Google Translator for readers wishing to view our LawPundit postings translated into one or more languages of their choosing.

However, it has been quite some time since we ourselves have given Google Translate a look. Much has happened in the interim.

Some years ago, the Google Translate translations of LawPundit postings were at best "moderately useful", but required substantial manual editing to obtain sufficient accuracy. Accordingly, it occurred to us recently that we should look anew at Google Translate translations of LawPundit postings for the two languages other than English that we ourselves speak fluently, German and Latvian.

The following translations (one here and one in the previous posting) are thus samples of Google Translate today, that we hope are representative for other languages as well. The translations are stunningly good, providing very useful results, but with a few exceptions, that in part surely depend on the writing clarity or unclarity of the original text.

One practical feature of Google Translate translations that we like is also that, when the reader hovers the mouse over a Google Translate translation of online material, the original text of the sentence underneath the mouse is shown in a text box. Try it out.

Below is the Google Translate German translation, without substantial subsequent editing [a few manual edits in brackets], of Science Research and the Role of Memes and Memetics : What Defines the Real Truth? with that title translated by Google Translate into German as Wissenschaftsforschung und die Rolle von Memen und Memetik: Was definiert die wahre Wahrheit? 

"Als Absolvent der juristischen Fakultät der Stanford University war der vorliegende Autor erfreut, im Scientific American at Science Research Needs an Overhaul zu lesen, dass John P.A. Ioannidis vor einigen Jahren ein neues Zentrum an der Stanford University namens METRICS ("the Meta-Research Innovation Center at Stanford") [etabliert hat], um das kostspielige Problem anzugehen, dass viel Mainstream-Forschung verschwendet wird.

Ioannidis zitiert die führende medizinische Zeitschrift The Lancet, die behauptet, dass diese „Verschwendung“ sogar für 85 % der medizinischen Forschung gilt, einer sogenannten „harten“ Wissenschaft.

Wie schlecht steht es dann in den Soft Sciences, wo der Beweisstandard wahrscheinlich niedriger ist als in der medizinischen Forschung?

Ioannidis schreibt, dass das METRICS-Zentrum:

„Ich werde versuchen, Forschungspraktiken zu untersuchen, und zu untersuchen wie diese optimiert werden können. Es wird die besten Mittel zur Gestaltung von Forschungsprotokollen und -agenden untersuchen, um sicherzustellen, dass die Ergebnisse keine Sackgassen sind, sondern vielmehr einen Weg nach vorne ebnen. Das Zentrum wird dies tun [...], indem Sie untersuchen, was die besten Möglichkeiten sind, um wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zuverlässiger und effizienter zu gestalten."

Diese Entwicklung begrüßen wir ausdrücklich.

Wir sind seit Jahren mit leichtgläubigen, uninformierten und eigensinnigen Menschen innerhalb und außerhalb der Wissenschaft konfrontiert, die die nahezu Unfehlbarkeit von Mainstream-Ideen und Forschungsmethoden verkünden, und wir haben wirklich wenig Geduld für solche Torheiten.

Da wir selbst Forschung an der Universität gelehrt haben, wissen wir aus Erfahrung, dass genau das Gegenteil von dem gilt, was die Wissenschaft behauptet...

und wahr ist, dass viel von dem, was in der Wissenschaft erforscht wird, und das als Ergebnis dieser Forschung veröffentlichte Peer-Reviews eine kostspielige Zeitverschwendung sind und die Wissenschaft oft in die falsche Richtung führen. Der Peer-Review-Prozess existiert teilweise, um die Federn der amtierenden Behörden aufzuplustern. „Wahrheit“ ist Nebensache.

Ein Hauptgrund für diese Torheiten der „wissenschaftlichen Forschung“, wie wir immer wieder geschrieben haben, ist, dass die Wissenschaft in der Vergangenheit überwiegend „autoritätsbasiert“ war, dh nicht das „Was“, sondern das „Wer“. bestimmt die Wahrheit in der Wissenschaft, und diese veraltete Praxis hat zu massiven Fehlern geführt. Vor dem Anbruch der Moderne war eine „autoritätsbasierte“ Wissenschaft notwendig, da Autoritäten die wichtigsten Wissensspeicher waren. Aber das hat sich in der Neuzeit stark geändert.

Schauen Sie sich nur die COVID-19-Coronavirus-Pandemie an, bei der die etablierten Wissenschaften in den letzten zwei Jahren trotz heldenhafter Bemühungen ihre Schwierigkeiten hatten. Die „Wissenschaft“ hätte besser auf die Pandemie vorbereitet sein müssen, als sie es war. Warum nicht?

Eine Verschiebung des Fokus der Wissenschaft ist unbedingt erforderlich. Die vorherrschenden Standards der Vergangenheit, als sogenannte "Autoritäten" die Wissenschaft beherrschten, sind heute in unserem digitalen Zeitalter, in dem jeder, der will, fast alles, was er will, online nachschlagen kann, oft fehl am Platz. Letzten Endes ist eine Autorität heute nur noch eine Meinung. Um eine sicherere menschliche Zukunft zu gewährleisten, muss die Wissenschaft von morgen auf bekannten Tatsachen beruhen, nicht auf bekannten Autoritäten.

„Evidence-Based Research“ muss in unserem digitalen Zeitalter oberste Priorität haben.

Veraltete Memes müssen langsam aufgegeben werden.

Aber was sind Meme?

Meme ist ein Begriff, der von Richard Dawkins, emeritierter Professor für Public Understanding of Science an der Universität Oxford in England, geprägt wurde.

Meme werden allgemein als „ nachgebildete Ideen, Symbole oder Praktiken “ definiert.

Wir sehen Meme als Beschreibung des Standes der Mainstream-Wissenschaft zu einem bestimmten Zeitpunkt und als Erklärung für viele ihrer Abweichungen. Meme verhalten sich wie Viren (oder Gene).

Ein Meme wird bei Wikipedia wie folgt definiert:

„“ [Ein]e Idee, Verhaltensweise oder Stilrichtung, die sich innerhalb einer Kultur von Person zu Person verbreitet.„ Ein Meme fungiert als eine Einheit, um kulturelle Ideen, Symbole oder Praktiken zu transportieren, die durch Schreiben, Sprache, Gesten, Rituale oder andere nachahmbare Phänomene mit einem nachgeahmten Thema von einem Geist zum anderen übertragen werden können. Befürworter des Konzepts betrachten Meme als kulturelle Analoga zu Genen, da sie sich selbst replizieren, mutieren und auf Selektionsdruck reagieren ... Das Wort Meme wurde vom britischen Evolutionsbiologen Richard Dawkins geprägt ... als Konzept zur Diskussion evolutionärer Prinzipien zur Erklärung der Verbreitung von Ideen und kulturelle Phänomene. Beispiele für Meme, die [in The Selfish Gene] gegeben wurden, waren Melodien, Schlagworte, Mode und die Technologie des Baus von Bögen."

Was in der Wissenschaft normalerweise als „Schule des Denkens“ bezeichnet wird, ist unserer Ansicht nach genauer als „Mem“ definiert, da „Denken“ oft nichts damit zu tun hat. Vielmehr verankern sich Ideen, zu Recht oder zu Unrecht, in verschiedenen Wissenschaftsdisziplinen und verbreiten sich, als hätten sie ein Eigenleben. Dasselbe gilt für Politik und Religion. Die Leute glauben Dinge aus Gewohnheit, mehr nicht.

Die Wahrheit ist überhaupt nicht das Problem.

Vielmehr, wie bei Wikipedia über Memetics geschrieben:

„Memetik ist eine Theorie des mentalen Inhalts, die auf einer Analogie zur darwinistischen Evolution basiert.... Befürworter beschreiben die Memetik als eine Annäherung an evolutionäre Modelle der kulturellen Informationsübertragung auf seinen Beitrag zur Leistungsfähigkeit seines Gastgebers zurückzuführen sein."

Dementsprechend und im Gegensatz zu der Vorstellung, dass „Wahrheit“ das Ziel in der Wissenschaft oder anderswo ist, halten Menschen tatsächlich an einer bestimmten Idee, Denkschule, kulturellen Praxis oder Religion fest, [weil die Anhänger eines bestimmten Mems es als Vorteil für die Inhaber dieses Mems wahrnehmen.]. Dieses grundlegende Verständnis hilft, viele Abweichungen zu erklären, die in der Wissenschaft entdeckt werden können, wobei [angeblich] "rationale" Menschen an längst überholten Ideen und Sichtweisen festhalten, oft im Widerspruch zu den verfügbaren Beweisen.

Wir schauen auf die beweiskräftigen Beweise!

Das macht unsere Arbeit aus."

 

Zinātnes pētījumi un mēmu un memētikas loma: kas nosaka patieso patiesību? Science Research and the Role of Memes and Memetics : What Defines the Real Truth? Google Translate Latvian Language Translation from LawPundit

In the right column of LawPundit, we offer the Google Translator for readers wishing to view our LawPundit postings translated into one or more languages of their choosing.

However, it has been quite some time since we ourselves have given Google Translate a look. Much has happened in the interim.

Some years ago, the Google Translate translations of LawPundit postings were at best "moderately useful", but required substantial manual editing to obtain sufficient accuracy. Accordingly, it occurred to us recently that we should look anew at Google Translate translations of LawPundit postings for the two languages other than English that we ourselves speak fluently, German and Latvian.

The following translations (one here and one in the posting following) are thus samples of Google Translate today, that we hope are representative for other languages as well. The translations are stunningly good, providing very useful results, but with a few exceptions, that in part surely depend on the writing clarity or unclarity of the original text.

One practical feature of Google Translate translations that we like is also that, when the reader hovers the mouse over a Google Translate translation of online material, the original text of the sentence underneath the mouse is shown in a text box. Try it out.

Below is the Google Translate Latvian translation, without substantial subsequent editing [minor edits in brackets], of Science Research and the Role of Memes and Memetics : What Defines the Real Truth? with that title translated by Google Translate into Latvian as Zinātnes pētījumi un mēmu un memētikas loma: kas nosaka patieso patiesību?

"Būdams Stanfordas Universitātes Juridiskās fakultātes absolvents, pašreizējais autors ar prieku lasīja žurnālā Scientific American pie Science Research Needs an Overhaul, ka Džons PA Joannidis pirms dažiem gadiem līdzdibināja jaunu centru Stanfordas Universitātē ar nosaukumu METRICS ("Meta-pētniecība". Inovāciju centrs Stanfordā ), lai risinātu dārgo problēmu, ka liela daļa galveno pētījumu tiek izšķiesti.

Ioannidis atsaucas uz vadošo medicīnas periodisko izdevumu The Lancet, kas apgalvo, ka šie "atkritumi" attiecas pat uz 85% medicīnas pētījumu, tā saukto "cieto" zinātni.

Cik slikti tad ir lietas mīkstajās zinātnēs, kur pierādījumu standarts, iespējams, ir zemāks nekā medicīniskajos pētījumos?

Ioannidis raksta, ka METRICS centrs:

"Mēģināsim izpētīt pētniecības praksi un to, kā to var optimizēt. Tajā tiks pārbaudīti labākie līdzekļi pētniecības protokolu un programmu izstrādei, lai nodrošinātu, ka rezultāti nav strupceļi, bet gan bruģē ceļu uz priekšu. Dariet to, izpētot, kādi ir labākie veidi, kā padarīt zinātnisko izpēti uzticamāku un efektīvāku .

Mēs ar entuziasmu atzinīgi vērtējam šo attīstību.

Mēs gadiem ilgi esam saskārušies ar lētticīgiem, neinformētiem un [pašpārliecinātiem] cilvēkiem gan zinātnē, gan ārpus tās, kas sludina galveno ideju un pētniecības metožu gandrīz nekļūdīgumu, un mums patiešām ir maz pacietības pret šādām muļķībām.

Paši mācīdami pētniecību universitātes līmenī, no pieredzes zinām, ka patiesība ir tieši pretēja tam, ko apgalvo zinātne...

un patiesība ir tāda, ka liela daļa no tā, kas tiek pētīts zinātnē, un tas ir salīdzinošais pārskats, kas publicēts šo pētījumu rezultātā, ir dārga laika izšķiešana un bieži vien virza zinātni nepareizā virzienā. Salīdzinošās pārskatīšanas process daļēji ir paredzēts, lai izpūstu valdošo iestāžu spalvas. "Patiesība" ir sekundāra lieta.

Viens no galvenajiem iemesliem šīm "zinātniskās izpētes" muļķībām, kā mēs esam vairākkārt rakstījuši, ir tas, ka zinātne pagātnē galvenokārt bija "balstīta uz autoritātēm", t.i., nevis "kas", bet gan "kurš" nosaka patiesību zinātnē, un šī novecojusi prakse ir radījusi milzīgas kļūdas. Pirms modernā laikmeta rītausmas "uz autoritātēm balstīta" zinātne bija nepieciešama, jo autoritātes bija galvenā zināšanu krātuve. Bet mūsdienu laikmetā tas ir ļoti mainījies.

Paskatieties uz COVID-19 koronavīrusa pandēmiju, kurā, neraugoties uz varonīgajiem centieniem, pēdējos divos gados ir bijušas grūtības iedibinātajām zinātnēm. "Zinātnei" vajadzēja būt labāk sagatavotai pandēmijai, nekā tā bija. Kāpēc tā nebija?

Zinātnes fokusa maiņa ir absolūti nepieciešama. Pagātnē dominējošie standarti, kad zinātnē valdīja tā sauktās "autoritātes", pašlaik mūsu digitālajā laikmetā bieži vien ir nevietā, kad ikviens, kas vēlas, tiešsaistē var meklēt gandrīz visu, ko vēlas. Pēdējā analīzē viena autoritāte šodien ir tikai vēl viens viedoklis. Lai nodrošinātu drošāku cilvēka nākotni, rītdienas zinātnei ir jābalstās uz zināmiem faktiem, nevis uz zināmām autoritātēm.

Mūsu digitālajā laikmetā galvenā prioritāte ir jāpiešķir "uz pierādījumiem balstītai izpētei".

No novecojušiem mēmiem ir lēnām jāatsakās.

Bet kas ir mēmes ?

Mēms ir termins, ko ieviesis Ričards Dokinss, Oksfordas universitātes Anglijā emeritētais profesors sabiedrības izpratnes jautājumos par zinātni.

Mēmas parasti tiek definētas kā "atkārtotas idejas, simboli vai prakse".

Mēs uzskatām, ka mēmi apraksta galvenās zinātnes stāvokli jebkurā laikā un izskaidro daudzas tās novirzes. Mēmas darbojas kā vīrusi (vai gēni).

Mēma Vikipēdijā ir definēta kā:

""[Ideja, uzvedība vai stils, kas kultūras ietvaros izplatās no cilvēka uz cilvēku. "Mēma darbojas kā kultūras ideju, simbolu vai prakses vienība, ko var pārnest no viena prāta uz otru, izmantojot rakstīšanu, runu, žestus, rituālus vai citas atdarināmas parādības ar atdarinātu tēmu. Koncepcijas atbalstītāji uzskata, ka mēmes ir kultūras analogi gēniem, jo ​​tie paši replikējas, mutē un reaģē uz selektīvu spiedienu... Vārdu mēms ieviesa britu evolūcijas biologs Ričards Dokinss [Richard Dawkins] ... kā jēdzienu diskusijām par evolūcijas principiem, izskaidrojot ideju izplatību un kultūras parādības. Mēmu piemēri, kas sniegti [izdevumā The Selfish Gene], ietvēra melodijas, īstās frāzes, modi un arku veidošanas tehnoloģiju."

Mūsuprāt, to, ko akadēmiskajā vidē parasti sauc par "domu skolu", precīzāk definē kā "mēmu", jo "domai" bieži nav nekā kopīga ar to. Drīzāk idejas, pareizi vai nepareizi, iesakņojas dažādās zinātnes disciplīnās un izplatās tā, it kā tām būtu sava dzīve. Tas pats attiecas uz politiku un reliģiju. Cilvēki tic lietām aiz ieraduma, nekam vairāk.

Patiesība nemaz nav problēma.

Drīzāk, kā rakstīts Wikipedia par Memetics : 

"Memētika ir garīgā satura teorija, kas balstīta uz analoģiju ar Darvina evolūciju... Piekritēji apraksta memetiku kā pieeju kultūras informācijas nodošanas evolūcijas modeļiem... Tāpat kā ģenētikā, īpaši Dokinsa [Dawkins] interpretācijā, mēma panākumi var būt tas ir saistīts ar tā ieguldījumu tās saimnieka efektivitātē."

Attiecīgi un pretēji priekšstatam, ka "patiesība" ir mērķis zinātnē vai citur, cilvēki tādējādi faktiski pieturas pie dotas idejas, domas skolas, kultūras prakses vai reliģijas , jo konkrētas mēmas piekritēji to uztver kā tādu, kas nodrošina tās turētājus tas mēms ar priekšrocībām. 

Šī būtiskā izpratne palīdz izskaidrot daudzas novirzes, kuras var atklāt zinātnē, jo, domājams, "racionālie" cilvēki stingri turas pie sen novecojušām idejām un veidiem, kā uz lietām skatīties, kas bieži ir pretrunā ar pieejamajiem pierādījumiem.

Mēs skatāmies uz pierādījumiem! 

Tas ir tas, kas nosaka mūsu darbu.

The Roots of Law: Prehistoric Mankind's Primary Technologies Were Rooted in Astronomy and the Prevailing Economies Were Based on Land and Property, Mapped via the Stars

Prehistoric Mankind's Primary Technologies Were Rooted in Astronomy and the Prevailing Economies Were Based on Land and Property, Mapped via the Stars

To understand the development of human civilization, it is important to recognize that mankind's first "scientific" technologies were arguably based on primitive "stargazing", i.e. what we modernly call "astronomy".

No less a thinker than Bertrand Russell wrote in Human Knowledge: Its Scope and Limits (Simon and Schuster, Clarion Books, New York, 1948) that:

"Astronomy is the oldest of the sciences, and the contemplation of the heavens, with their periodic regularities, gave men their first conceptions of natural law."

Furthermore, there is a direct connection to astronomy in terms of both land survey and land or sea navigation, as written at the Wikipedia under Surveying:

"The primary way of determining one's position on the earth's surface when no known positions are nearby is by astronomic observations. Observations to the sun, moon and stars could all be made using navigational techniques. Once the instrument's position and bearing to a star is determined, the bearing can be transferred to a reference point on the earth and which can then be used as a base for further observations. Survey-accurate astronomic positions were difficult to observe and calculate and so tended to be a base off which many other measurements were made. Since the advent of the GPS system, astronomic observations are rare as GPS allows positions to be determined adequately over most of the surface of the earth."

Since human survival has at all times depended on either ownership or control of actual physical territory on our planet Earth, that same astronomy served as the simplest way to map out that territory, with maps made to mirror the ever-present and ready-made sky map of the heavens, "as above, so below".

At our Megaliths.net website on megalithic cultures we have written:

"As observed by Alice Cunningham Fletcher (Alice C. Fletcher) in her 1902 publication in the American Anthropologist, there is ample evidence that some ancient cultures, e.g. the Pawnee in Nebraska, geographically located their villages according to patterns seen in stars of the heavens. Fletcher, A. C. (1902), Star Cult Among the Pawnee – A Preliminary Report, American Anthropologist, 4:730–736. doi:10.1525/aa.1902.4.4.02a00050."

To the importance of astronomy for ancient peoples we can add timekeeping, as written some time ago at Curious About Astronomy:

"In ancient times, the practical need for timekeeping and navigation was one of the primary reasons for the study of astronomy. The celestial origins of timekeeping and navigation are still evident."

In spite of the above observations, anthropologists and archaeologists worldwide generally proceed in their academic work as if the ancients knew more or less nothing of astronomy and, furthermore, placed little or no importance upon it for land survey, navigation, timekeeping and chronology, whereas the probative evidence that we have increasingly found presents exactly the opposite picture.

Astronomy DOMINATED the ancient world, and was in this manner at the root of human legal systems and societies, in mapping land and property on Earth.

Science Research and the Role of Memes and Memetics : What Defines the Real Truth?

As a Stanford University Law School graduate, the present author was pleased to read in the Scientific American at Science Research Needs an Overhaul, that John P. A. Ioannidis some years ago co-founded a new center at Stanford University called METRICS ("the Meta-Research Innovation Center at Stanford") to deal with the costly problem that much mainstream research is wasted.

Ioannidis cites to leading medical periodical, The Lancet, which avers that this "waste" applies even to 85% of medical research, a so-called "hard" science.

How bad are things then in the soft sciences, where the standard of proof is likely lower than in medical research?

Ioannidis writes that the METRICS center:

"[W]ill seek to study research practices and how these can be optimized. It will examine the best means of designing research protocols and agendas to ensure that the results are not dead ends but rather that they pave a path forward. The center will do so by exploring what are the best ways to make scientific investigation more reliable and efficient."

We enthusiastically applaud this development.

We have been confronted for years by gullible, uninformed, and opinionated people in and out of science proclaiming the near infallibility of mainstream ideas and research methods and we really have little patience for such follies.

Having taught research ourselves at the university level, we know from experience that exactly the opposite of what is claimed by science is true...

and what is true is that much of what is researched in science and that is peer-review published as a result of that research is a costly waste of time and often leads science in the wrong directions. The peer-review process exists in part to fluff the feathers of the reigning authorities. "Truth" is a secondary matter.

One main reason for these follies of "scientific research", as we have written time and time again, is that science in the past has been predominantly "authority-based", i.e. it is not the "what" but the "who" that determines truth in science, and this outdated practice has led to massive errors. Before the dawn of the modern age, "authority-based" science was necessary since authorities were the key repositories of knowledge. But that has greatly changed in the modern era.

Just look at the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic where the established sciences have had their difficulties the past two years, despite heroic efforts. "Science" should have been better prepared for the pandemic than it was. Why was it not?

A shift in the focus of science is absolutely necessary. The prevailing standards of the past, when so-called "authorities" ruled the roost in science, are currently often misplaced in our digital age when anyone who wishes can look up nearly anything they want online. In the last analysis, one authority today is just one more opinion. In order to insure a more secure human future, the science of tomorrow must be based upon known facts, not upon known authorities.

"Evidence-Based Research" must be given top priority in our digital age.

Outdated memes must be slowly abandoned.

But what are memes?

Meme is a term coined by Richard Dawkins, emeritus Professor for Public Understanding of Science at Oxford University in England.

Memes are defined generally as "replicated ideas, symbols or practices".

We view memes as describing the state of mainstream science at any given time and to explain many of its aberrations. Memes act like viruses (or genes).

A meme is defined at the Wikipedia as:

""[A]n idea, behavior, or style that spreads from person to person within a culture." A meme acts as a unit for carrying cultural ideas, symbols, or practices that can be transmitted from one mind to another through writing, speech, gestures, rituals, or other imitable phenomena with a mimicked theme. Supporters of the concept regard memes as cultural analogues to genes in that they self-replicate, mutate, and respond to selective pressures.... The word meme was coined by British evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins ... as a concept for discussion of evolutionary principles in explaining the spread of ideas and cultural phenomena. Examples of memes given [in The Selfish Gene] included melodies, catch-phrases, fashion, and the technology of building arches."

In our view, what is normally called a "school of thought" in academia is more accurately defined as being a "meme", because "thought" often has nothing to do with it. Rather, ideas, rightly or wrongly, become entrenched in various disciplines of science and propagate themselves as if they had a life of their own. The same is true for politics and religion. People believe things out of habit, nothing more.

Truth is not at all the issue.

Rather, as written at Wikipedia about Memetics: 

"Memetics is a theory of mental content based on an analogy with Darwinian evolution.... Proponents describe memetics as an approach to evolutionary models of cultural information transfer.... As with genetics, particularly under a Dawkinsian interpretation, a meme's success may be due to its contribution to the effectiveness of its host."

Accordingly, and contrary to the notion that "truth" is the objective in science or elsewhere, people thus actually adhere to a given idea, school of thought, cultural practice or religion because the adherents of a particular meme perceive it as providing the holders of that meme with advantages. 

That essential understanding helps to explain many aberrations that can be discovered in science whereby presumably "rational" people hold fast to long-outdated ideas and ways of looking at things, often at odds with the available probative evidence.

We look to the probative evidence! 

That is what defines our work.

 

The Rule of Law, Winston Churchill, and the History of Civilization : The Battle Against Tyranny and Monopolistically-Inclined Thinking

The Rule of Law, Winston Churchill, and the History of Civilization: The Battle Against Tyranny and Monopolistically-Inclined Thinking
 

The "History of Civilization" is a concept which many people in academia misunderstand, thinking the study of the history of culture and technology to be the realm of specialized vested-interest historians or monopolist-like professions.

 

Alternatively seen, when we speak of the history of civilization, we must consider that the actual progress of mankind may have been substantially different than currently portrayed in over-creative, oft unsubstantiated documentaries on television or other media. Indeed, it is very likely that the "priests" of ancient cultures were, above all, less interested in pots and pottery, the realm of modern Archaeology, but were rather stargazers and land surveyors, comparable in their day to our astronomers and mapmakers.

 

As written by John Bedell at Bensozia in Aztec Surveying:

 

"The two things that drove mathematical progress in ancient civilizations were land surveying and astronomy."

 

"Civilization" thus may encompass a broader perspective than that presented to us by current science, and we need to grant such a possibility a greater audience.

We quote Winston S. Churchill, “Civilization,” Chancellor’s Address, University of Bristol, July 2, 1938, via Niall Ferguson in Civilization: The West and the Rest and Michael Kaplan at The New Jacksonian Blog, citing to Winston S. Churchill, Blood, Sweat, and Tears, Randolph S. Churchill, ed. (New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1941), pp. 45-46:

 

"There are few words which are used more loosely than the word “Civilization.” What does it mean?

 

It means a society based upon the opinion of civilians. It means that violence, the rule of warriors and despotic chiefs, the conditions of camps and warfare, of riot and tyranny, give place to parliaments where laws are made, and independent courts of justice in which over long periods those laws are maintained.

 

That is Civilization—and in its soil grow continually freedom, comfort and culture. When Civilization reigns, in any country, a wider and less harassed life is afforded to the masses of the people. The traditions of the past are cherished, and the inheritance bequeathed to us by former wise or valiant men becomes a rich estate to be enjoyed and used by all.

 

The central principle of Civilization is the subordination of the ruling authority to the settled customs of the people and to their will as expressed through the Constitution.

 

In this Island [Great Britain] we have today achieved in a high degree the blessings of Civilization. There is freedom: there is [the rule of] law; there is love of country; there is a great measure of good will between classes: there is a widening prosperity. There are unmeasured opportunities of correcting abuses and making further progress."

 

Despite those wonderful words of wisdom by Winston Churchill more than 80 years ago, we today live in an allegedly "modern" era where the cardinal virtues of Civilization are greatly under siege and where we can only view the future with a certain amount of trepidation. World news is still dominated daily by conflict and strife rather than by progress and peace. Science still suffers from great and colossal failings, despite heroic efforts, as the current pandemic teaches us all.

It may of course be argued that Civilization always wins in the end and moves onward or even forward, but it is always a battle against the forces of yesteryear and against various monopolistically inclined nations, groups, religions, organizations, and schools of thought, that always have -- and today continue -- to strive to bind mankind in the chains of blindered ignorance and superstition.

 

It is our duty, especially the best and most capable of us, to counter the selfish voices of despots and tyrants, small and large, whether in politics or academia.

 

We must lead positively into the future.

 

That is always the pioneer spirit behind our own work.

 

SKY EARTH NATIVE AMERICA "Rock Art" Contents by Topic for Volumes 1 and 2

SKY EARTH NATIVE AMERICA

"Rock Art" Contents by Topic for Volumes 1 and 2

In Inupiaq (also spelled Inupiat) Eskimo language
an inuksuk is "a native Alaskan cairn built to mark pathways".
See Behind the Name.

The existence of such rock "landmarks" in Native America is thus undisputed in principle.  

We take this knowledge one level further and show that megalithic and petroglyphic rock carvings and pictographic rock art served as landmarks placed by the stars, i.e. astronomy, using the ready "mirror" map of the starry sky in the hermetic tradition, "as above, so below".

That is the "Sky Earth" of Native America, whose rock "stars" are the stars of the heavens, immortalized by the ancients via the rocks of our Earth. These landmarks were placed systematically in Native America and can be reconstructed.

Sky Earth Native America -- in Two Volumes
Native American Rock Art Petroglyphs Pictographs  Cave Paintings Earthworks & Mounds
Deciphered as Land Survey & Astronomy by Andis Kaulins, paperbacks in color print

Sky Earth Native America Volume 1-----------Sky Earth Native America Volume 2
by Andis Kaulins J.D. Stanford                                          by Andis Kaulins J.D. Stanford

Contents by Topic for Volume 1 of Sky Earth Native America

• Preface 
• Prologue 1: The History of Civilization: Winston Churchill on the Rule of Law as a Prerequisite to Human Progress 
• Prologue 2: Anthropomorphic Rocks Featured in America's 1st Surrealist Film, Object Lesson, already in the year 1941 
• Prologue 3: Book Publications by the Author on Law, Legal History, and Ancient Astronomy and Land Survey: 
• The Great "Google Earth" Image Mystery 
• The Great "Google Earth" Image Mystery: Hints to Solution 
• Judaculla Rock Cherokee Dividings : Research Beginnings 
• Starry Night Pro as our Astronomy Software for Research 
• Judaculla Rock Decipherment 1 
• Petroglyphs of North Carolina and Georgia Mark Stars 
• Two Petroglyph Boulders of Northeast Georgia near Helen Mark Stars of Canis Major, Canis Minor, Orion & Taurus 
• Allen Rock Petroglyphs in Habersham County, Georgia USA Mark Stars of the Heavens Principally Orion 
• Hiawatha: Holder of the Heavens: A Solution to The Great Google Earth Image 34.890653 -83.880198 Mystery 
• Hiawatha as Atlas and Orion, the Iroquois Aron-Hiawagon with Hiawagon = Hiawatha, the "Holder of the Heavens" 
• Prehistoric Mankind's Primary Technologies Were Rooted in Astronomy; Economies Were Based on Land & Property 
• The Great Mound, Petroglyph and Painted Rock Art Journey of Native America Begins! [Posting #1 of this Series] 
• Grave Creek Mound Archaeological Complex Moundsville, West Virginia Marks Cygnus [Posting #2 of this Series] 
• The Center of the Mound System of Native America: Great Serpent Mound, Newark, Chillicothe [Posting #3 of the Series] 
• The North Ecliptic Pole and Draco as Marked by the Newark Earthworks in Ohio [#4] 
• Draco and the Hopewell Mounds of the Mound City Necropolis in Chillicothe, Ohio [#5] 
• Precession: North Celestial Pole and Ursa Minor as Marked by Mounds and Earthworks in Chillicothe, Ohio [#6] 
• Criel Mound Dunbar South Charleston West Virginia Mark Stars of Cepheus and North Celestial Pole in ca. 300 BC [#7] 
• Wolf Plains Mounds of Ohio as Southeasterly Stars of Draco Near the North Ecliptic Pole [#8] 
• Google Earth Pro Free as of February 1, 2015 
• The Paint Creek Valley Mounds, Seip and Baum Earthworks, and Fortified Hill in Ohio as Stars of Ursa Major near the Big Dipper and North Celestial Pole [#9] 
• The Great Serpent Mound in Ohio Marks Stars of Draco & Mounds and Earthworks Help to Calculate Precession [#10] 
• Effigy Mounds National Monument, Harpers Ferry, Iowa, as Stars of Libra, Boötes, Ursa Major, Perseus, Pleiades [#11] 
• Effigy Mounds at Poverty Point, West Carrol Parish, Louisiana as Astronomy: Thunderbird of the Pleiades [#12] 
• Poverty Point Needs Review [#13] 
• Painting in Cave of Indian, Tamaulipas, Burgos Municipality Mexico, Marks Taurus, Orion ca. 2300 B.C. [#14] 
• John Bedell on Aztec Surveying & Ancient Civilizations: Land Survey and Astronomy Drove Mathematical Progress 
• Las Labradas Petroglyphs Baja California Sur Mexico Mark Tropic of Cancer Summer Solstice Canis Major [#15] 
• Sierra de San Francisco El Vizcaino Reserve Baja California Sur in Mexico: Rock Art as a Sky Map ca. 1000 B.C. [#16] 
• A Baseline X,Y Axis for An Ancient Native North America Land Survey with a Portrait of an Astronomical Land Surveyor as an Ollama Game Player on Tlachtli [#17] 
• Etowah Ocmulgee Lamar Mounds Georgia Mark Summer Solstice ca. 1200 A.D. and 1450 A.D. Respectively [#18] 
• Great Thunderbird Challenge for World's Archaeologists, Astronomers Archaeoastronomers: 1 Petroglyph 60 Stars! 
• The State of Modern Archaeology and Astronomy: Thundering Acclaim for the Thunderbird Challenge or Not? 
• Y-Axis of Native North America Land Survey – Herschel, Saskatchewan Canada to Ancient Sites in Mexico [#19] 
• The Bottom of the Y-Axis of the Ancient Native North America Land Survey by Astronomy in Mexico: Monte Alban, Santos Reyes Nopala, Mitla, Rio Copalita [#20] 
• Rock Art Sites of Southern Saskatchewan, Canada, Mark Stars of Scorpio and Autumn Equinox ca. 3000 B.C. [#21] 
• Herschel Petroglyphs, Monoliths & Rocks Mark Primarily Stars of Scorpio and Autumn Equinox ca. 3000 B.C. [#22] 
• Herschel Petroglyphs Monolith #1 as Sky Map ca. 3000 B.C. and Survey Plan of Ancient Native North America [#23] 
• Herschel Petroglyphs Monolith #2 Marks Stars at Head of Scorpio Marking Autumn Equinox ca. 3000 B.C. [#24] 
• Herschel Petroglyphs Monolith #3 Marks Scorpio [#25] 
• Thunderbird of Roche Percée Petroglyphs of Saskatchewan Canada Marks Stars Below Hydra by Canis Major[#26] 
• Temple of Seven Dolls Dzibilchaltun Merida Marks Front Shield Stars of Orion at Celestial Equator ca. 200 B.C. [#27] 
• Mitla in Oaxaca Mexico Marks Stars of Lepus Columba [#28] 
• Palenque Chiapas Mexico Marks the Stars of Columba [#29] 
• Texas Man-With-Raised-Arms Petroglyph Marks Stars of Taurus at Palo Duro Canyon (2nd largest in USA) [#30] 
• North Dakota Mounds at Valley City State University Medicine Wheel Park Mark Stars of Serpens Caput and Ophiuchus and the Autumn Equinox in ca. 3000 B.C. [#31] 
• The Megalith of Cañon el Porvenir Zaragoza, Coahuila, Mexico near the Twin Peaks of Los Picos de Davis and near Del Rio, Texas Marks Gemini ca. 3000 B.C. [#32] 
• Rock Art Sites in Southwestern Arizona Mark Stars of Leo and the Summer Solstice ca. 3000 BC at Quitobaquito [#33] 
• Toltec Mounds Arkansas Mark Stars of Auriga as a Boat, plus Milky Way, Galactic Equator & Galactic Meridian [#34] 
• Spiro Mounds in Oklahoma Mark Stars Between Gemini Auriga and Lynx and Mark the Galactic Meridian [#35] 
• Cahokia Mounds Platforms & Palisades Mark Stars of Ursa Major as a Bow-and-Arrow Wielding "Galactic" Hunter [#36] 
• Cahokia Monks Mound Birdman : Mystery of Official Cahokia Logo Tablet and Monks Mound [#37] 
• Cahokia Monks Mound : The Missing Heart[#38] 
• Cahokia at the Heartland of Ancient Native America! [#39] 
• Cahokia Birdman Tablet Has Sky Map Etched on the Stone Surface: The Crosshatch Back Side Diagonals Each Marked Six Degrees of the Heavens: The Birdman was Surely the "Astronomer Surveyor Priest" [#40] 
• The Winterville Mississippi Mounds Mark Theta Aurigae at Mound A and Nearby Stars in Auriga Lower than the Upper Toltec Mounds Star Menkalinan [#41] 
• Marksville Emerald Mound and 46 Locations in Louisiana and Mississippi Mark Stars of Auriga: The Indian Trail Natchez Trace Thus Followed Edge of the Milky Way [#42] 
• Moundville Earth Mounds near Tuscaloosa Alabama Mark Stars of Perseus [#43] 
• The Shelton Stone Mound Complex Group 2 near Jacksonville Alabama Marks Stars of Perseus [#44] 
• The Shelton Stone Mound Complex Group 1 Marks Stars of What We Today Call Camelopardalis Above Perseus [#45] 
• Shelton Stone Mound Complex Group 3 near Jacksonville Alabama Marks the Pleiades and Stars of Aries [#46] 
• Flinders Petrie and the Shelton Mound Wall and Boulder Complex Groups 1 2 3 Together as a Weaver & Vertical Warp-Weighted Backstrap-Type Loom [#47] 
• The Bottle Creek Mounds North of Mobile Alabama Mark the Stars of the Pleiades [#48] 
• Ancient Mounds of the Florida Peninsula Mark the Stars of Cetus -- Crystal River Mounds, Horr's Island (now the "other" Key Marco), Miami Circle and More [#49] 
• Crystal River Mounds of the Crystal River Archaeological State Park in Florida Mark Stars at the Head of Cetus [#50] 
• Crystal River Mounds Megalith (Stela #1) Deciphered [#51] 
• The "Next" Great Google Earth Image Mystery [#52] 
• Brickell Point Miami Circle Florida as a Sky Map[#53 - #57] 
• Miami Circle, Nazca, Northern Hemisphere Sky Map, Aztec Calendar Stone, Izapa Stela 5, Google Earth Mystery  [#58] 
• Location of Next Google Earth Image Mystery Image [#59] 
• The Fact Avoidance Syndrome in Mainstream Science 
• Nazca (Nasca) Mystery Image as Anthropomorphic Cupule Marking of Stars of Andromeda and Pisces on Earth [#60]
  

Contents by Topic for Volume 2 of Sky Earth Native America

• Book Publications by the Author on Law, Legal History, and Ancient Astronomy and Land Survey
  
• Mounds of the State of Florida Revised Map includes Mound Key as a Map of North America ca. 1150 B.C. [#61] 
• The Ultimate Test for Art and Archaeological Aptitude - "ArtArchApt" Shows Your "ArtArchAptness" [#62] 
• Mound Key and Other Sites in the Estero Bay Aquatic Preserve South of Fort Myers Florida as Stars of Cetus [#63] 
• Dali and da Vinci through July 26, 2015 at "the Dali" Museum in St. Petersburg: Minds Machines & Masterpieces 
• The Lake Jackson Mounds in the Florida Panhandle Mark a Rectangle of Stars to the Left of the Head of Cetus at the Lower Extremity of the Stars of Taurus [#64] 
• The Grand Mounds at Little Talbot Island State Park in Northeast Florida near Jacksonville mark Ecliptic, Vernal Equinox, and Calculate Precession ca. 240 B.C. [#65] 
• Shields & Grant Mounds at the Mill Cove Complex Jacksonville Florida Have the Shape of a Fishhook & Fishing Weight as Located at the Mouth of Pisces [#66] 
• Alternative Browser "Pale Moon" as a Fork of Mozilla Firefox but No Australis Keeps Firefox 28 Customizability Including Tabs BELOW the Address Bar and Full Profile Migration 
• Shell Rings Sapelo Island Darien Georgia Mark Upper Stars of Pisces as Early Snorkeler Water Serpent Whale/Manatee, Shark, Sardine, Octopus, Starfish and Tropical Fish [#67] 
• Pinson Mounds in Tennessee -- Largest Middle Woodland Mound Complex in the USA -- Sauls Mound, Ozier Mound, Earthworks -- Mark the Stars of Cassiopeia as a Bird [#68] 
• Terra Ceia Island and Madira Bickel Mounds Between St. Petersburg and Bradenton Florida Represent Stars in Cetus as Mortar Pestle Dough & Bakers Peel [#69] 
• Long Key White Sand Mound Boca Ciega Bay Gulf Coast Florida St. Petersburg as Stars of Cetus and Eridanus [#70] 
• It's Not What You Say, It's What People Hear: Sequential Presentation of Information More Important than Content 
• Big Mound City and the Big Circle Mounds in Florida Marked Neighboring Groups of Stars in Cetus Separated by the Celestial Meridian in ca. 670 A.D. [#71] 
• Philip Earthworks at Lake Marion, Florida show the Circle of Stars at 34 Ceti, 38 Ceti, 39 Ceti and 42 Ceti, with 34 Ceti the Star On the Edge of the Circle [#72] 
• Fort Center Lakeport Florida Mounds Earthworks Mark Cetus Left of Stars Marked by Big Circle Mounds [#73] 
• Letchworth-Love Mounds Monticello Florida's Largest Pre-Columbian Earthworks, Mark Stars of Aries [#74] 
• Kolomoki Mounds Blakely Largest in Georgia mark the Bright Stars of Aries at the Vernal Equinox ca. 200 BC [#75] 
• Antiquarian Discovery Charles Dickens Pickwick Papers 
• Tick Island DeLeon Springs Lake Woodruff Florida marks Stars at the Circlet of Pisces [#76] 
• Rollins Shell Ring and "Ringlet" Mounds Fort George Island Cultural State Park Jacksonville Florida, SW of the Grand Mounds Little Talbot Island State Park, Mark Stars of Pisces at Alpha Piscium and Portray a Man of Native America [#77] 
• Tomoka Mounds Middens Ormond Beach Florida Mark Primarily the Stars of the Lower Fish of Pisces as a Shark with the Head to the Left and the Body to the Right [#78] 
• Turtle Mound Largest Shell Midden USA Near New Smyrna Beach in Florida Marks Delta Piscium and the Mount Royal Temple Mound Near Welaka Marks Xi Piscium: Map of Florida Mounds of the Lower Fish of Pisces [#79] 
• Does Mankind Really Want Mysteries of the Past to be Solved? Facts as Unwanted Visitors in the World of Academic and Other Wishes and Emotions [#80] 
• Native America Contributions to Modernity: Maize (Corn), the Potato, the Tomato, Tobacco, and Machu Picchu [#81] 
• Machu Picchu Peru Marks Ophiuchus in its Architectural Design Construction as Inca Cosmological Levels[#82] 
• Intihuatana (Inti Watana) at Machu Picchu as Solar Apex, Apex of Sun's Way on its Galactic Orbit in the Galaxy [#83] 
• Other Stars Marked in the Environs of Machu Picchu? [#84] 
• Cognition of Geographic Information and Human Spatial Orientation : Systems of Landmarks in Ancient Eras 
• Population Genetics Puts Origins of Indo-European Languages in the East in the Corded Ware Kurgan Culture 
• New Genetic Research Says Human Out of Africa Migration Was Via Egypt and Not Via Ethiopia 
• Saksaywaman in Cuzco, Peru Represents Aquila as the Quechua ch'aska kancha "Stellar Constellation" Cha(s)kay Waman, the Falcon Constellation [#85] 
• SaksayWaman as Star Groups of the Heavens Between Tullu Mayu and Sapphi Mayu, the Ends of the Milky Way [#86] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman as Inca Astronomy - Image 1 of 14 Decipherment Images taken Left to Right – Here Marking Libra, Virgo, Corvus, and the Equinox Line [#87] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman as Inca Astronomy: Image 2 of 14 Marks Crater & Tail of Hydra [#88] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman - Image 3 of 14 Marks Leo Cancer Hydra Canis Minor & Major and Canopus [#89] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 4 of 14 Marks Orion Gemini Taurus Auriga [#90] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 5 of 14 Marks Perseus Pleiades Aries Andromeda Pegasus [#91] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 6 of 14 Marks Cassiopeia Equinox Cepheus [#92] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 7 of 14 Marks Draco Aquila Cygnus Lyra Ophiuchus Cygnus Cepheus [#93] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 8 of 14 Marks Serpens Caput Sagittarius [#94] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 9 of 14 Marks Inca ATOQ the Fox, Scorpio (tail to the left) [#95] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 10 of 14 Marks the Great Llama Centaurus Lupus [#96] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 11 of 14 Marks Llama Cancha Yutu Tinamou [#97] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 12 of 14 Marks Crux the Southern Cross [#98] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 13 of 14 Marks Dark Constellations Toad Hanp'atu Serpent Mach'acuay [#99] 
• Decipherment of SaksayWaman: Image 14 of 14 Marks the End Section of Mach'Acuay the Dark Constellation [#100] 
• A "Readable" Full Decipherment Photo Image for SaksayWaman via a Link to the Bitmap [#101] 
• Qurikancha Gold Altar Map Cuzco Peru Inca Inti Sun Temple as Crux Southern Cross plus Milky Way and Galactic Meridian [#102] 
• Rock Art Ererê Brazil Uses Same Astronomical System as Found at Cusco: Inscripcoes em rochedos do Brasil Figure 4 Hartt: First of a Series of Six Postings [#103] 
• Rock Art Ererê Brazil Figure 5 Hartt[#104] 
• Rock Art Ererê Brazil Figure 6 Hartt[#105] 
• Rock Art Ererê Brazil Figure 7 Hartt[#106] 
• Rock Art Ererê Brazil Figure 10 Hartt[#107] 
• Rock Art Ererê Brazil Figure 1 Hartt[#108] 
• "Heart of the World" at La Ciudad Perdida, the Lost City of Colombia, South America, Marks the Stars of Corvus and Also Has a Southern Hemisphere Sky Map Megalith [#109] 
• Petroglyph Boulders viz. Petroglyphic Megaliths as Former Tribal Boundaries in Native America [#110] 
• Kokopelli as Boötes Playing Flute Extending to Ursa Major: Mortendad Cave Petroglyphs Los Alamos New Mexico USA as Marking Stars of the Heavens ca. 1750 B.C. [#111] 
• Kokopelli as Kokopetiyot (koko-petiyot): Boötes the Herdsman with Flute or Horn[#112] 
• Blythe Intaglios California Arizona Border as Astronomical Tribal Landmarks Involve Environmental Suits[#114] 
• Painted Rock, La Piedra Pintada, Carisa Rock viz. Carrol Rock, Carrizo Plain, San Luis Obispo County, Largest Pictograph Site in California, Marks Stars of Virgo [#115] 
• Keystone Petroglyphs Mendocino County, California, Mark Stars of Virgo at the Autumn Equinox ca. 500 B.C. [#116] 
• Spyrock (Spy Rock) Petroglyphs Mendocino County California Mark Stars of the Sky ca. 3000 B.C. [#117] 
• The Klamath River Petroglyph Boulder as Sky Map [#118] 
• A "Virgo" Fertility Origin for the Name of Oregon? [#119] 
• Roosevelt Washington Columbia River Rock Inscriptions at Horsethief Lake State Park are Sky Map ca. 750 B.C. in the Shape of a Dog-like Animal's Head like Machu Picchu [#120] 
• Lost Slakaiya Rock Petroglyphs of Eel River California are a Sky Map ca. 3400 B.C. and Perhaps an Ancient Map of the Northern Pacific Northwest Including Alaska [#121] 
• Rock Formation at Big Butte Montana Marks Boötes [#122] 
• Pictograph Cave State Park Montana Giant Cliff Wall "Cupules" (Holes) as Stars ca. 3000 B.C. [#123] 
• Medicine Wheel Locations in Alberta, Canada Mark Stars of Sagittarius, Corona Australis and Telescopium [#124] 
• Distribution of Pictographic Rock Art Sites in Alaska and a Decipherment Map as Astronomy by Location [#125] 
• Tuxedni Bay Clam Cove Alaska Carvings Rock Art SW of Anchorage: Tuxedni as Cygnus Clam Cove as Aquila [#126] 
• Alaska Rock Art Geographic Distribution Corresponds to Traditional Tribal Territorial Divisions of Cultures [#127] 
• Feniak Lake Alaska Noatak National Preserve 3-Sided Megalith Marks Stars & Astronomical Parameters [#128] 
• Rumsen Rock Presidio Monterey California Near the Sloat Monument is Fertility "Virgo Megalith" [#129] 
• Rio Hurtado Valley Norte Chico Chile Rock Art Deciphered as Crux Centaurus Musca ca. 600 A.D. [#130] 
• Anasazi Ancestral Pueblo Rock Art St. George Ivins Utah as Sky Map from Serpens Cauda to Aquila ca. 1000 B.C. at the Emergence of the Early Basketmaker Era II . [#131] 
• Skaitok Boulder Spence's Bridge British Columbia Canada as a Sky Map of Stars Similar to Anasazi Pictographs [#132] 
• Sambaqui - Shell Midden Mounds of Santa Catarina, Brazil, Jabuticabeira Region Mark the Turtle viz. Tortoise of Heaven as the Stars of Columba at the Bottom of the World [#133] 
• The Great Google Earth Eagle Mystery Challenge and the Seven Principles of an Eagle: The Eagle as the Messenger to the Great Spirit, the Creator [#134] 
• A First Nations Clue to the Location of the Eagle of The Great Google Earth Eagle Mystery Challenge: The Boundary Commission Trail as the Oldest Highway in the West and the Boundary Between the USA and Canada [#135] 
• Manitoba Manitou and the Eagle [#136] 
• A Hypothetical Ancient Land Survey Map of Native America and the Cahokia Birdman Tablet Compared [#137] 
• Location of the Mystery Eagle at the "Old" Pilot Mound, Manitoba: Aquila in Land Survey of Native America [#138] 
• Jeffers Petroglyphs of Minnesota as Sky Maps ca. 750 B.C. Minnesota Marks the Stars of Hercules [#139] 
• Petroglyphs of Area of Slabs, Area das Lajes, Amazon Basin, Manaus, Brazil, as a Sky Map ca. 3000 B.C. [#140] 
• The Equator Megalith of Brazil Highway BR-174 North of Manaus near Rorainópolis, State of Roraima, Brazil [#141]